Homosexuality 'thriving' despite strict criminal code
A ban on kite-flying failed to dampen the spirits of party-goers in
Lahore at the weekend, where hundreds of parties took place to
celebrate the age-old Basant festival. But one gathering stood out.
Under a starry sky filled with fireworks, about 150 gay men
clambered to the roof of an apartment building for an exuberant party.
Bollywood music spilled into the streets as dress-wearing men twisted
and whirled flamboyantly.
Some older men with moustaches and wearing traditional shalwar
kameez stared silently from the sidelines. But most of the party-goers
were in their 20s, dressed in jeans and T-shirts, and looking for a
good time. "We just want to have fun," said one of the organizers,
known as the "hot boyz".
Homosexuality is taboo in Pakistani society, where sexual
orientation is rarely discussed and the gay rights debate is
non-existent. Sodomy is punishable by up to life in jail, and religious
leaders condemn gay men as an aberration of western corruption.
When President Pervez Musharraf boasted of empowering minorities,
during a press conference with George Bush in Islamabad 10 days ago, he
was unlikely to have been referring to gay emancipation. Yet many
homosexuals say their community is quietly thriving, often with the
tacit acceptance of a society which prefers to look the other way.
Assaults on gay men are rare; sodomy laws are seldom invoked.
Communities of Hijra - a transsexual group, with roots which
stretch back to the Mughal empire - are found in all major cities. "In
a bizarre way homosexuality is condemned but not opposed," said a gay
man from Karachi. "There is an indulgence here, a cultural ability to
live and let live."
Such matters gain little political capital. When Urdu-language
newspapers accused a former chief minister of Sindh province of being a
cross-dresser two years ago, the storm quickly blew over and the
politician kept his job.
The apparent open-mindedness is at odds with Pakistan’s austere and
socially conservative image abroad. Last year Punjabi authorities
briefly banned female participants in marathon races, while sex outside
marriage between men and women is punishable by death.
Cultural factors offer one explanation - gay men can easily
camouflage their relationships because public displays of affection
between men, such as holding hands, are widely accepted. "Western gays
are gobsmacked about how easy it is to pick up guys here, how often
they are approached," one gay man said.
Nevertheless, homosexuality, like anything related to sex, is
practiced with great discretion. Internet chat rooms provide a safe and
anonymous forum for middle- and upper-class gay men. Cohabiting couples
are rare, and most gay men still marry to avoid scandalizing their
families.
An Afghan refugee sparked controversy in the Khyber tribal agency
last September when he was "married" to a 16-year-old boy. A tribal
council ordered the pair to leave, or be stoned for breaking religious
and tribal values.
And many Pakistanis ignore their existence, seeing homosexuality as
an abhorrent, western practice. "It is not allowed in Islam and is
surely against the laws of nature; it is one of the signs of the end of
the world," a contributor to a BBC Online debate recently wrote.
Unlike vocal gay rights activists in western countries, many
Pakistani gay men feel that the lack of debate suits them. "If we were
being actively persecuted, then we might fight in public," said a gay
man in Islamabad. "But you don’t want to pick a fight you can’t win."
Source: Guardian Magazine